S1E25 – Against All Gods
Based on Mythology Island
The episode starts an hour or two after Episode 24’s ending. Piper and Jack had sneak out of the house and use the blimp to go to a very mysterious island, or a very mysterious tree to be more exact. By the time they get there, it’s just after sunrise. Turns out the book was just about all these treasures in Poptropica, and Piper wanted to find the Golden Apple of Immortality. Jack, who only just found this out, told Piper that it wasn’t a good idea. Apparently many people in the past had tried to find it, but they never came back. Piper shrugs it off. Then Jack asks why she wants to be immortal in the first place. Piper realized she doesn’t have a good reason for it, but at the same time, she doesn’t want to die. So she just grabs the apple before Jack can say how selfish that is. Nothing happens for a moment, the apple just sits there. Jack says that immortality can’t just grow on trees, and that something feels weird about this. And then Zeus shows up. She had some idea of the Poptropican gods from Poptropolis, but no one had told her that they were actually real…
Then it’s basically the plot of Mythology Island, getting all the items and stuff. Only when they go to the Underworld, they find all the other people who had tried becoming immortal. Yep, they died on the quest, rip. Also it’s revealed that everyone is forced to wear tunics there cause Zeus prefers the days of Poptropolis and they don’t want to make him mad. They’re allowed to use cell phones and stuff, though.
And then it’s more of the island plot, all the way to Piper literally fighting Zeus…and somehow winning. Only this time, Zeus never says he’s going to be good. He says he’s going to be back.
So after all that, Piper and Jack decided to make up an excuse for why they were away all day. Piper’s mistake was a pretty stupid one, to say the least. They never told Jack’s parents what really happened. They wouldn’t find out for months…